SHRO-Reports
REPORT ON THE SITUATION OF HUMAN RIGHTS IN THE SUDAN,
SEPTEMBER 2000
The efforts to achieve a political comprehensive settlement
for the crisis of Sudan witnessed an important development in September
2000. The Second Congress of the opposition National Democratic Alliance
(NDA) was convened. A meeting was held between the NDA President and the
head of the ruling regime, and in relation to that the regime's National
Congress Party held an exceptional meeting as well.
The NDA Masawa' Congress was convened between 9 and 13
September towards ending the war and constructing a New Sudan. The Congress
priority agenda adopted the option of a comprehensive political settlement.
A meeting was held on September 26 between general Omer Hassan Al-Bashir,
the president of the republic and Al-Sayed Mohamed Osman Al-Mirghani,
the NDA President, in Asmara the capitol of Eritrea. The two partners
emphasized the concern for peace and the stability of Sudan can only be
achieved by a comprehensive political settlement not by military action.
The partners said they were determined to put a quick end for the war
and to create the conditions conducive to the voluntary unity and the
reconstruction of the country.
The Asmara meeting, the first of its type, was considered
as an exploratory meeting after which direct negotiations would be made
to enforce a comprehensive settlement to end the crisis of Sudan. This
certainly is a difficult task. Although the meting was a significant step
that broke the ice it is not as yet conducive to the final settlement.
On one side, the government has not positively responded to the NDA requirements
to take appropriate measures for a fruitful dialogue. The government has
not canceled the non-democratic provisions of the act of national security
and the law of political parties. It has not yet guaranteed the freedom
of political parties and trade union activities. The government has not
yet unites the forum of the political dialogue. The opposition considered
these measures as a vital procedure to move into the cancellation of the
constitution for the sake of a transitional constitution. Then to change
the existing government, enforce the formulation of a national government
to execute the program of the transitional government, establish a new
basis for the voluntary national unity, and specify a date for the constitutional
conference.
On the other side, the government's position is not serious
concerning the political settlement. It appears, the government deals
with the ongoing efforts to make a comprehensive political settlement
only to strengthen government program and fundamental issues. This is
ascertained by the statement that the ruling Congress Party issued in
the conference it held during September 27-29. The conference called for
"an exercise of freedoms within the framework of the law and the
constitution." Both of these are not agreed upon. The conference
assured the peaceful dialogue must be taken "with commitment to the
political and constitutional principles that represent the high values
of the nation and preserve the high interests and the wise political practice
without totalitarianism or party chaos". More than ever , the exceptional
congress of the ruling party that was held after to the Asmara meeting
between Al-Mirghani and Bashir confirmed, "there would be no retreat
from the Islamic Shari'a and the fixed principles of the National Salvation,
or the federal government".
In addition to all this, the government continues to prepare
for a parliamentary and presidential national election. Voting was scheduled
on December 11-20 for all states. The 24th of December was set for the
final results of the election. This clearly indicates the government is
determined to rule out the participation of the other parties.
This September, a new IGAD round of talks was conducted
between the Khartoum government and the SPLM. The talks were made in the
Baringo district west of the Kenyan capitol Nariobi. The agenda included
the distribution of wealth, autonomous rule of the South, religion and
state, and the right of self- determination for the territories of southern
Kordofan, the Ingessana, and Abyai. The talks were concluded in the first
week of October to no avail.
Before the IGAD talks, the government announced a cease-fire
in the South for two weeks. This announcement came about with an accusation
by the government that the SPLM had been violating the cease-fire and
obstructing the regular delivery of relief aid to the South. The government,
however, was continuously violating the cease-fire truce. On September
14, for example, the government air raids bombarded with 17 bombs the
village of Aktos in Eastern Equatoria (20 miles off the Sudanese-Ugandan
border). Two persons were injured and 24 houses were demolished. After
4 days, the government airforce bombed the village of Naros (10 miles
of the Sudanese-Kenyan border) with 11 bombs. A dispensary run by the
Catholic Church was largely destroyed. Two persons were killed and 11
injured. SHRO-Cairo strongly condemned these attacks on the innocent civilians
The Organization condemned the government for using schools, hospitals,
and houses as military targets. SHRO-Cairo called upon the government
to stop all these serious violations against civilians.
The emergency law continued all over September as an additional
violation of public freedoms and the privacy of citizens' political and
civil rights.
Violating Women's Right to Work
On September 5, the governor of Khartoum, Dr. Mazoub Al-Kahlifa,
issued the decision no. 84 to prohibit women from work in hotels, restaurants,
and gas stations. SHRO-Cairo and many other organizations in the country
expressed deep concerns about the decision that violates Article 23 of
the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. The Article says: "Every
one has the right to work, to free choice of employment, to just and favourable
conditions of work and to protection against unemplyment."). The
decision also violates Article 1 (2) of the International Convention on
Civil and Political Rights. The decision by the Khartoum governor is a
gross violation of the women's right to work that is guaranteed by the
Sudanese national law including the 1998 constitution of the regime.
Despite the fact that the constitutional court issued
another decision in September 9 that suspended the decision of the governor,
the governor announced his rejection to the court's decision. He said
his decision already transcended the stage of issuance to that of execution
and entrenchment. The constitutional court did not take any position against
the governor. Galal Ali Lutfi, the head judge of the court, issued a decree
that prohibited the press and citizens from commenting on the matter.
He said that all comments would affect the due process of justice. The
head of the high constitutional court said that any comment or discussion
published on the case against the governor of Khartoum before his court
would decide on the matter would lead to a criminal prosecution of the
press.
The decision of the governor was not a personal decision.
It is part of the general orientation of the State. This is confirmed
by the support the governor's decision met on the part of the legislative
body of the Khartoum State. They publicly announced that the decision
was congruent with the Shari'a Law, the constitution, labor law, and the
tourism and hotels act. Many other officials supported the decision of
the governor. Ghazi Salah El-Deen, the minister of culture and information,
affirmed that the governor "took his decision as a responsible personal
appreciation of the case, according to his jurisdiction and responsibilities."
The authorities violently reacted to a peaceful march
by the women who tried to deliver a memo protesting the governor's decision
to the council of ministers. The security forces and the police used tar
gas and heavy sticks to beat the women of whom many were injured and arrested.
Arrests
The SHRO-Cairo received reliable information on arrests
of 26 women who participated in the march of September 1. The list of
detainees included: Gamar Abd Allah Mohamed Salih, Aziza Awad, Ni'ma Awad
Al-Seed, Nagat Abu Al-Gasim, Rahsa Abd Allah, Safa Abd Al-Rahman, Taiba
Abdel-Rahman Sharif, Sahar Mohamed Tahir, Fayza Abu Bakr Mustafa, Alawiya
Ahmed Siddiq, Maha Yaqoub, Nimat Yaqoub, In'am Abd Allah, Saliha Abd Allah
Saeed, Mahasin Mustafa, Mona Mohamed Tahir, Kawthar Ibrahim, Zeinab Ali
Al-Umda, Amira Yousif Abu Tawila, Salwa Saeed Abd Al-Karim, Nazik Mahgoub
Osman, Awadiya Al-Haj, Zahra Faysal, Intisar Al-Toam, Wisal Abd Al-Mageed,
and In'am Abd Allah Saeed.
The SHRO-Cairo reported in a statement issued on September
12 that the human rights of women in particular were violated in spite
of the constitution, the constitutional court decision, and the Sudanese
norms. The violation was equally committed against all charters and conventions
that respect human rights, especially articles 9 and 20 of the international
convention concerning arbitrary arrests. SHRO-Cairo condemned the governor
of Khartoum and drew the attention of the government to these gross violations.
SHRO-Cairo called upon all regional and international human rights organizations
and women's organizations in particular to put the pressure on Sudan government
and the governor of Khartoum to cancel his decision and abolish all laws
that curtail the public freedoms.
On September 16, the security forces arrested Al-Zain
Al-Awad Khidir, a leader of the Democratic Unionist Party (DUP) in Omdurman
without any legal accusation. Al-Zain was transferred to an unknown place.
His car and his mobile phone were confiscated. On September 20, the security
forces arrested at the Kharotum Airport Dr. Adam Mohamed Ahmed, another
leader of the DUP, at the Khartoum Airport on his way back from the Asmara
Congress. The arrest of Adam was made without any formal accusation against
him. His family failed to know his detention center and his lawyers were
not allowed to meet with him.
On September 22, the security forces arrested 4 political
activists of the Sudanese Communist Party in Al-Hasahisa town to the south
of Khartoum. The arrested persons included: Affifi Ismail, Ab Al-Raouf
Omer, Ja'far Abd Al-Raziq, and Mutassim Ibrahim Bashir. They were taken
to the city of Meddani the same day of their arrest without any formal
accusation or legal order.
The arrests included tens of students in the cities of
Kosti, Khartoum, PortSudan, Al-Obeid, and Nyala following massive public
protests by students against expensive school fees, the deterioration
of education services, and the government's campaigns of compulsory conscription.
In Kosti, a student of a secondary school was killed and tens were injured
in confrontations with the police. 120 students were arrested and put
to trial of whom many were flogged. Some citizens including lawyers were
arrested. These citizens included Zaki Mansour, Al-Rasheed Ali Omer, and
Sayed Hassan Al-Toam among others.
In Khartoum, a number of students were arrested for a
peaceful demonstration in which students of Al-Neelain University and
the Sudan University for Sciences and Technology were actively participating.
In Al-Obeid, the Kordofan University students and other
secondary school students demonstrated in protest of national service
following the crash of a car of the national service with Haytham Ballah
Khalil, a citizen riding a bicycle who was injured in the accident. The
national service officers were trying to recruit Haytham and other citizens
by force.
In Northern DarFur the police confrontation with citizens
led to the killing of a female student, Rasha Abd Allah, and the injuries
of 8 other students as well. The city of Port Sudan witnessed many attacks
by the police against peaceful students who were protesting the imposition
of expensive school fees of more than 20,000 pounds on every student in
the elementary and secondary education. The authority claimed the demonstrations
were politically motivated.
During September, the security forces intensified security
work against the personnel and supporters of the national popular congress
party that is led by Hassan Al-Turabi. The party said 50 of its personnel
were arrested in Al-Fashir, Nyala, the Red Sea, and Khartoum. The names
of the detainees included: Idrees Omer Al-Nour, Mukhtar Hamza, Rashid
Abd Al-Qadir, Majdi Awad, Walied Ali Karoam, Muawiya Abd Al-Gadir, Amin
Shannan, Abd Allah Bilal, Hassan Mohamed Nour, Ahmed Mohamed Ahmed, Ahmed
Abd Al-Rahman, Mohamed Farouq, Al-Rasheed Abubakr, Nafi' Mohamed Omer,
Mohamed Ali Mohamed Osman, Haytham Abd Al-Mageed, Abdeen Ali Hassan, Hassan
Abd Allah, Adham Osman, Hatim Satti Abd Al-Gadir, and Al-Amin Ahmed Shaikh
Al-Deen. In Al-Fashir, the party said these were arrested: Abd Allah Mohamed
Adam Al-Doma, the party secretary of North DarFur, Mekki Hamid Balilla,
Ibrahim Salih Sharif, Abd Allah Adam Abu Dandoosh, Adam Juma' Abou, Adam
Sa'ad Al-Nour, Abd Allah Ibrahim Haroun, Issam Al-Deen Yaqoub Ali, Ahmed
Shareef Bashr, Mohamed Mahmoud Omer, Mohamed Suliman, Faysal Abd Al-Mageed,
Al-Haj Adam, Abd Al-Nasir Abubakr, Abd Allah Biraima Fadl, Mohamed Abd
Al-Raheem Fadl Allah, Osdman Mohamed Ibrahim, Jawhar Suliman Ali, Mussadaq
Mohamed Ali Inggal, Abd Al-Rasoul Abd Allah Abd Al-Rasoul, Suliman Abbbaker
Adam, and Hamza Al-Hadi. In Nyala, the party said many of its members
were arrested including Idam Abubakr Islamil, Ahmed Abd Al Rahman, Al-Tigani
Seneen, Ahmed Adam Bakhiet, Zuhair Hamid Bellah, and Salah Al-Zain the
party's youth leader.
The popular congress party said many of its members were
arrested in the capital Khartoum accused of an assassination attempt on
the life of a journalist who supported the government. Many of the party
students were arrested while demonstrating with the University of the
Holy Qur'an in Omdurman the closing week of September. Haj Magid Swar,
a student and member of the leadership of the party, and Mohamed Abd Al-Rahman,
the high education secretary of the Islamic students movement, were also
arrested.
A number of government officials accused the popular congress
party of making demonstrations against the government and of planning
to sabotage. The party ejected the accusations and accused in turn the
government of restricting the right to free expression. The party accused
the government of occupying the party premises in Fashir, and Nyala. On
September 14, the authorities prevented delegates of the popular congress
party from arrival at the Fashir Airpot as they were forced to return
to Khartoum by the same plane.
The National Service Campaigns
The government continued to conscript the youth and students
from streets and public places to the conscription camps. The national
service campaigns were excessively violent. They led to violence in the
States of the While Nile and Kordofan.
In the White Nile State, the conscription campaign led
to the killing of a citizen who tried to escape the national service.
The governor blamed the national service headquarters for the violent
events that erupted in the city of Kosti as a result of the killing. In
the town of Rabak, Kamal Rajab Abd Al-Gadir died of the torture and harsh
training of the national service. These were exercised in the city stadium
that had been earlier converted to a training camp for more than a year.
The murdered person was a businessperson who was forced to conscript in
June. He was taken to the hospital where he immediately died. The authorities
claimed he died of malaria. The diseased family said he had been in good
health preparing for his wedding when he was forcibly conscripted then
killed by the national service authorities.
Despite the strong criticisms of citizens against the
national service violations, the government is determined to continue
with that. The spokesperson of the national service said there were negative
aspects of the conscription campaigns. He affirmed, however, the service
would continue to examine the necessary documents to recruit all of the
citizens who could not be called upon through school or the work place.
In Khartoum, Ayoub Bashir Mohamed was beaten and humiliated
by members of the service although he was not eligible to conscription.
He was pulled by force from his car before the hospital, smacked down
and beaten. His body was severely injured according to medical reports.
Freedom of the Press
September witnessed the arrest and trial of a number of
journalists and writers. Many were required to come before the Prosecutor-General's
office for criticisms published on officials of the State. For example,
the Prosecutor for Crimes Against the State summoned 3 prominent journalists
concerning essays criticizing a statement by Amin Bananni, the state minister
at the ministry of justice. Bannnai accused the Central Bank of Sudan
of hiding significant information on the financial contravention by some
banks. Mahgoub Irwa, a publisher and writer, and Nour Al-Deen Meddani,
the deputy editor-in-chief of Al-Sahafa journal, and Osman Mirghani, a
writer of Al-Ray Al-Am daily, were repeatedly asked to meet with the Prosecutor-General's
office for investigation. The journalists said they were asked to stay
for long hours without any interrogation.
The authorities arrested Alola Berhi Kabdani, the director
of the research and information bureau of the Al-Ray Al-Akhir newspaper.
Kabdani's place of detention is still unknown. The authorities did not
formally accuse him although he was arrested and detained. In September,
the writer Hassan Ibrahim was accused of publishing an article in Al-Ray
Al-Akhir in which he raised many accusations against the governor of Khartoum.
Al-Nour Ahmed Al-Nour, the secretary general of the government-controlled
Sudanese Journalists' Association, expressed deep concerns for the intimidation
the journalists met while doing their work through the summons issued
by the Prosecutor-General's Office concerning crimes against the State.
September further witnessed a dangerous attempt to assassinate
a government-supporter journalist, Mohamed Taha Mohamed Ahmed the editor-in-chief
of Al-Wifaq journal. The accident was related to a harsh article Mohamed
Taha published in the issue no. 963 of the journal on September 21. Taha
was attacked after a meeting with the National Council for Press and Publications
where he was told his journal was suspended for 5 days. The suspension
order read: "the article was a violation of the Sudanese morals and
principles. It was an expression of gross indecency and a worldly and
Day-After bankruptcy."
|